Interpreting Standard Deviation
What standard deviation tells you
Standard deviation measures how far the values in a data set are from the mean. The more scattered the values, the larger it is. It tells you nothing about whether the average itself is high or low.
On the SAT you will almost never have to calculate it. You compare the spread of two data sets, or you decide what happens to the standard deviation when the data changes. I teach this every year in AP Statistics, and the students who do well are the ones who picture the spread instead of reaching for a formula.
Standard deviation questions on the SAT come in three kinds: comparing two data sets, predicting what a change does to the spread, and reading the spread from a dot plot or a list. In every one of them, the question you are really answering is how far the values are from the middle.
Spread, and what changes it
Tightly clustered data has a small standard deviation. Widely scattered data has a large one. Two data sets can have exactly the same mean and very different standard deviations. If every value is identical, the standard deviation is $0$.
Most SAT questions about standard deviation are really about change. Once you know the rules in this table, you can answer them without any arithmetic.
| What happens to the data | Mean | Standard deviation |
|---|---|---|
| Add the same number $c$ to every value | Goes up by $c$ | No change |
| Subtract the same number from every value | Goes down by that number | No change |
| Multiply every value by $k$ | Multiplied by $k$ | Multiplied by $|k|$ |
| Remove a value far from the mean (an outlier) | Moves toward the rest of the data | Decreases |
| Add a value far from the mean | Moves toward the new value | Increases |
| Add a value equal to the mean | No change | Decreases slightly |
Three examples
Example 1: two sets with the same mean
Set A is $48, 49, 50, 51, 52$. Set B is $30, 40, 50, 60, 70$. Which has the larger standard deviation?
- Find the middle of each set. Both have a mean of $50$.
- Look at the distances from $50$. Set A: $2, 1, 0, 1, 2$. Set B: $20, 10, 0, 10, 20$.
- Set B's values are ten times farther from the mean, so Set B has the larger standard deviation. You don't need the formula for this.
Example 2: removing an outlier
A data set is $12, 14, 15, 16, 43$. What happens to the mean and the standard deviation if $43$ is removed?
- The mean is $\dfrac{12 + 14 + 15 + 16 + 43}{5} = \dfrac{100}{5} = 20$.
- Without $43$, the mean is $\dfrac{57}{4} = 14.25$. The mean decreases.
- $43$ was the value farthest from the mean. The four values left are close together, so the standard deviation decreases too.
Example 3: adding the same amount to every value
Quiz scores have a mean of $62$ and a standard deviation of $4$. The teacher adds $7$ points to every score.
- Every score moves up by $7$, so the mean becomes $62 + 7 = 69$.
- Every score moves the same amount, so each score's distance from the mean is unchanged.
- The standard deviation stays $4$. Moving the whole data set up does not spread it out.
The empirical rule
When data is roughly bell-shaped (symmetric, with most values near the middle), the standard deviation tells you where the values fall:
- About $68\%$ of values lie within $1$ standard deviation of the mean.
- About $95\%$ lie within $2$ standard deviations.
- About $99.7\%$ lie within $3$ standard deviations.
The darker band holds about $68\%$ of the data. Add the two lighter bands and the whole shaded area, within $2$ standard deviations, holds about $68\% + 13.5\% + 13.5\% = 95\%$.
Example 4: using the empirical rule
Heights of a large group of students are roughly bell-shaped with a mean of $64$ inches and a standard deviation of $3$ inches.
- One standard deviation on each side: $64 - 3 = 61$ and $64 + 3 = 67$. About $68\%$ of heights are between $61$ and $67$ inches.
- Two standard deviations on each side: $64 - 6 = 58$ and $64 + 6 = 70$. About $95\%$ are between $58$ and $70$ inches.
- The other $5\%$ is split evenly between the two ends, so about $2.5\%$ of students are taller than $70$ inches.
The SAT itself rarely asks about the empirical rule by name. It is still worth knowing: it turns "one standard deviation" into a picture you can use, and it is standard material in AP Statistics and on many state tests. It only works for data that is roughly bell-shaped, not for skewed data.
Mistakes I see often
Linking standard deviation to the mean. A higher standard deviation means more spread, not a higher average.
Confusing standard deviation with range. Range uses only the two extreme values. Standard deviation reflects every value.
Thinking a shift changes the spread. Adding or subtracting the same number from every value moves the mean but leaves the standard deviation unchanged.
Ignoring outliers. One value far from the rest raises the standard deviation a lot. Removing it lowers the standard deviation.
Using the empirical rule on skewed data. The $68\%$, $95\%$, $99.7\%$ pattern only holds when the data is roughly bell-shaped.
Practice questions
Most of these can be done without calculating anything. Picture the spread first, then open the solution to check your reasoning.
- ADataset X
- BDataset Y
- CThey have the same standard deviation
- DIt cannot be determined without calculating
Show solution
- A$1$
- B$78$
- C$0$
- DIt cannot be determined from the information given
Show solution
- AGroup 2
- BThey are equally spread out
- CIt cannot be determined without the data values
- DGroup 1
Show solution
- AMean $62$, standard deviation $11$
- BMean $69$, standard deviation $4$
- CMean $69$, standard deviation $11$
- DMean $62$, standard deviation $4$
Show solution
- AThe mean decreases and the standard deviation increases.
- BThe mean stays the same and the standard deviation decreases.
- CBoth increase.
- DBoth decrease.
Show solution
- A$3$
- B$5$
- C$6$
- D$9$
Show solution
- AThe means are equal, and List B has the larger standard deviation.
- BList A has the larger mean and the larger standard deviation.
- CThe means are equal, and List A has the larger standard deviation.
- DThe lists have the same mean and the same standard deviation.
Show solution
Empirical rule practice
For each question, the data is roughly bell-shaped, so the $68\%$, $95\%$, $99.7\%$ pattern applies.
- A$34\%$
- B$68\%$
- C$95\%$
- D$99.7\%$
Show solution
- A$61$ and $67$ inches
- B$58$ and $70$ inches
- C$55$ and $73$ inches
- D$62$ and $66$ inches
Show solution
- A$2.5\%$
- B$5\%$
- C$16\%$
- D$32\%$
Show solution
- A$62$
- B$70$
- C$78$
- D$86$
Show solution
Find your exact gaps
Take a free, full-length practice test and see precisely which question types trip you up.
Practice this for free